At 8 pm, a long line stretched through the Hop. The lead trumpeter for the band had collapsed, had CPR, and was taken by ambulance to the hospital. We learned this during the show, which started quite late. Fortunately, the other trumpeter (David Ellis?) was able to sight read the lead trumpet parts, and the show went on!
This was a strong slate of finalists, all great singers. For the first half, each sang a solo. In particular, Tyné Freeman sang Black Gold, with a great overhead video celebrating black people. She had been in the master class with Cécile McLorin Salvant in September. Brooke Bazarian sang God Bless the Child, one of my favorites, and one of the few songs I recognized. The 2 weakest singers, but not by much, were Alyssa and Trevor. Of course, Alyssa sang first, and that is a hard slot.
In the second half, each singer sang a duet with a past Dartmouth Idol winner or finalist. I was glad to see Nikhil Arora back. I had voted for him last year, and thought he should have won. He was also a background vocalist, many of whom were Idol alumni like him. Tyné sang a duet with Grace Carney last year’s winner, but it was really two songs, with Tyné singing the first one, and Grace singing the second one, mostly solo.
Host Rachel Dratch was hilarious, especially with her reference to her dorm rooms at the River Cluster. Hopefully the Trustees in attendance will pay attention to the problem of student housing. But she was very good, and very funny throughout. The judges were appropriately complimentary, with good feedback from Kaitlyn, and some zany stuff from Deby. The unofficial co-host was Walt Cunningham, who, as always, talked a bit too much about himself, but he does know how to put on a great show.
This year the voting was electronic, so you sent a text to 650-600-9016 with a number code (140917 for Tyné). That went smoothly, and it meant that they could announce the winner, Brooke Bazarian within minutes. The stage was full for the final song, to serenade us as we left into a cold winter night.
It is a real treat to have this show available to us at Dartmouth – thanks Walt!
Dartmouth News Article: Starry, Starry Night: Dartmouth Idol Finalists Take the Stage
April 27 Follow-up: Finally the true story about why the show was delayed.